Ir para o conteúdo
Voltar aos guias

Atualizado

Not a US Citizen: Which Presence Test Applies to a Green Card Holder in Puerto Rico?

A green card holder is a resident alien for tax purposes, so the five-alternative presence test applies. A nonresident alien uses the substantial presence test with Puerto Rico substituted.

Soft blue, cyan and rose light over a fine grid, with the One83 app mark
Illustration: One83.

Which presence test applies to a non-citizen in Puerto Rico?

It depends on whether you are a resident alien or a nonresident alien. A green card holder is a resident alien, so the same five-alternative presence test that applies to a US citizen applies to you. A nonresident alien uses a different test. Both come from 26 CFR 1.937-1, the regulation behind section 937.

The presence test is only one of three tests. A bona fide resident of Puerto Rico must also have no tax home outside Puerto Rico and no closer connection to the United States or a foreign country. The Form 8898 instructions list all three as conditions that must be met together.

Who counts as a resident alien and who as a nonresident alien?

A resident alien, for this purpose, is an alien individual defined in section 7701(b)(1)(A). A nonresident alien is an alien individual who is not a resident alien. Section 937 does not draw that line itself. It borrows it from section 7701(b) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Under section 7701(b)(1)(A), an alien is a resident for a calendar year if, and only if, one of three things is true:

  • The individual is a lawful permanent resident of the United States at any time during the year. That is the green card test.
  • The individual meets the substantial presence test.
  • The individual makes the first-year election in section 7701(b)(4).

A lawful permanent resident, under section 7701(b)(6), is someone who has been lawfully accorded the privilege of residing permanently in the United States as an immigrant, where that status has not been revoked or administratively or judicially determined to have been abandoned. A treaty tie-breaker can end that treatment in some cases.

So a green card holder is a resident alien. Someone with no green card is a resident alien only through the substantial presence test or the election, and otherwise is a nonresident alien. Which of these describes you in a given year, particularly a year in which your status changed, is a question for your tax advisor.

How does the presence test work for a resident alien?

The presence test for a resident alien is the same five-alternative test that applies to a citizen. 26 CFR 1.937-1(c)(1) applies it to "a United States citizen or resident alien individual" as defined in section 7701(b)(1)(A). You meet it for the year if you satisfy any one of these:

  1. You were present in Puerto Rico for at least 183 days during the year.
  2. You were present in Puerto Rico for at least 549 days over the year and the two preceding years, and for at least 60 days in each of those three years.
  3. You were present in the United States for no more than 90 days during the year.
  4. Your earned income in the United States did not exceed $3,000 in total, and you were present for more days in Puerto Rico than in the United States.
  5. You had no significant connection to the United States during the year.

The Form 8898 instructions list the same five. The IRS webinar on territory residency, which says it is not official guidance, states the point plainly: the five ways of meeting the presence requirement apply to US citizens and residents.

A significant connection, as defined in 1.937-1(c)(5)(i), is any one of three things: a permanent home in the United States, current registration to vote in a US political subdivision, or a spouse or child under 18 whose principal place of abode is in the United States. For the numbers in one place, see every presence test number with its citation.

How are days counted for a resident alien?

A day counts as a day in Puerto Rico if you are physically present there at any time during the day. That rule is in 1.937-1(c)(3)(i)(A). A day spent in both the United States and Puerto Rico counts as a day in Puerto Rico under (c)(3)(iii)(A).

Some days spent elsewhere also count as Puerto Rico days: days outside the possession for qualifying medical treatment, and a 14-day period after a major disaster or days under a mandatory evacuation order. A day in transit between two points outside the United States, with fewer than 24 hours in the United States, is not a day of US presence. The full list is in the regulation, and the guide on what counts as a day in Puerto Rico walks through it.

What if you are a nonresident alien?

A nonresident alien meets the presence test by passing the substantial presence test of 301.7701(b)-1(c), with Puerto Rico's name substituted for the United States where appropriate. That is the special rule for alien individuals in 1.937-1(c)(2).

Ordinarily the substantial presence test measures days in the United States. Here the day counting runs against Puerto Rico instead. The five alternatives in the previous section are not available to you. The IRS webinar says so directly: they apply only to US citizens and residents.

Both tests use the number 183, but they are different tests. The article on the two different 183 day tests sets them side by side. The details of the nonresident alien test, including how its weighting works, are in the regulation cited above and are worth taking to your advisor before you rely on a count.

Do a green card holder's tax home and closer connection tests change?

No separate rule for aliens appears in the regulation for either test. Paragraph (d)(1) says an individual meets the tax home test if they did not have a tax home outside Puerto Rico during any part of the year. Paragraph (e)(1) says an individual meets the closer connection test if they did not have a closer connection to the United States or a foreign country than to Puerto Rico during any part of the year.

A tax home is the regular or principal place of business or, if there is none, the regular place of abode in a real and substantial sense. For the closer connection test, the Form 8898 instructions list these factors: the location of your permanent home, your family, your social, political, cultural, professional or religious affiliations, your routine personal banking, your driver's license, and the charities you support.

Both tests compare your ties to Puerto Rico against your ties to the United States and to foreign countries, so a green card is one fact among many, not a deciding one. The framework is explained in presence test, tax home and closer connection.

What is left to your advisor?

Three points the regulation cannot settle for you. Whether you are a resident or nonresident alien in a given year comes from section 7701(b). How a change in immigration status during a year interacts with the year-of-move rules depends on your facts. And which return you file, and where, depends on your status and income. Treat each as a question for a licensed professional, not as something to infer from this page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a green card holder use the same presence test as a US citizen?

Yes, in the sense that 26 CFR 1.937-1(c)(1) applies one set of five alternatives to a US citizen or a resident alien. A green card holder is a resident alien under section 7701(b)(1)(A)(i), so any one of the five alternatives is enough for the presence test. The tax home and closer connection tests must still be met.

What presence test does a nonresident alien use?

Under 26 CFR 1.937-1(c)(2), a nonresident alien meets the presence test by satisfying the substantial presence test of 301.7701(b)-1(c), with Puerto Rico's name substituted for the United States where appropriate.

Do the tax home and closer connection tests change for non-citizens?

The regulation states both tests for an individual in paragraphs (d) and (e) and gives no separate alien rule for either. All three tests must be met for the year.

Who decides whether I am a resident alien or a nonresident alien?

Section 7701(b) of the Internal Revenue Code draws that line, not section 937. Applying it to your facts, including any year in which your status changed, is a question for your tax advisor.

One83 is a tracking tool, not tax advice. Consult a licensed tax professional about your situation.

One83 é uma ferramenta de registro, não assessoria fiscal. Confirme a sua situação com um profissional qualificado.

Voltar aos guias